Insights · Small business & hospitality

We Saw This Coming

David Lee argues unemployment at a near five-year high was predictable: wage rises kept coming without the policies to lift productivity and support business.

By 21 October 2026 · 3 min read

An empty restaurant with set tables and leather chairs and no diners

Unemployment has just hit its highest level in nearly five years. Small business owners have been warning about this for years, and nobody in Canberra was listening.

The numbers

The Australian Bureau of Statistics reported last week that the unemployment rate rose to 4.7% in September. That is the highest since October 2021. Employment fell by 39,300 people in a single month, and 732,000 Australians are now out of work.

4.7%.

This didn’t come out of nowhere. Ask anyone running a café, a kitchen, a shop or a trade business and they’ll tell you they saw it coming.

Only one end of the equation

Every year the wage decision comes down, and every year the focus is on one thing: lifting wages. Award wages went up 3.5% in July 2025 and another 4.75% in July 2026.

I’m not against people being paid properly. Good staff are the business. But a wage is paid out of what a business earns, and nobody has done anything to help businesses earn more.

Every time wages went up, there should have been something alongside it to grow the business environment and carry that increase. A productivity measure. A policy that helps a business do more with the people it has. Instead we got the cost and none of the support.

Productivity went nowhere

Even the Fair Work Commission said it. In its 2025 decision it wrote that Australia’s “continuing poor performance in labour productivity growth” held back the size of the increase.

The latest national accounts show output per hour worked fell 0.2% in the year to June 2026. So wages keep rising and productivity doesn’t. Something has to give, and what gives is jobs.

When costs rise and income doesn’t, a small business owner has three choices: put prices up, cut hours, or stop hiring. Most of us have done all three. Multiply that across every small business in the country and you get the number the ABS published last week.

A few suggestions

A wage rise needs a plan to pay for it. Here are a few ideas that could sit alongside every wage decision.

  • A tax break for productivity spending. When wages go up, give small business an extra deduction for the equipment, software and training that help each person produce more. We’ve had versions of this before: the technology investment boost ended in June 2023 and the skills and training boost in June 2024. The wage rises were permanent. The support wasn’t.
  • A pay rise matched by a skills rise. Fund short, practical courses through TAFE for people already in the job, free to small business. In a kitchen that’s multi-skilling, prep and production methods, costing and food safety. The worker earns more and can do more, and the business can afford it.
  • Cut the cost of employing. Make the awards simpler to roster and pay correctly, and cut the compliance paperwork. If wages go up, the hidden costs of employing someone should come down.

Lift productivity and higher wages pay for themselves. Lift wages on their own and you end up exactly where we are now.

Small business has been saying this for years. It’s time the government started listening.

If this is hitting your business, I work with hospitality owners on costs.

Sources

Add your voice

What’s hurting your business?

Tell me, and I’ll take it into my next interview.

More insights

All insights