Insights · Small business & hospitality

Unemployment at 4.9%: This Isn’t Just a Cycle

David Lee argues unemployment at 4.9% is more than a rate cycle: small businesses have stopped growing and hiring, and rate cuts alone won’t bring the jobs back.

By 19 November 2026 · 4 min read

Café chairs stacked on tables outside a closed restaurant

Today’s jobs numbers came out, and unemployment has jumped to 4.9%, the highest in five years. We lost 43,500 jobs in October. Economists expected the rate to hold steady and about 25,000 jobs to be added, so they got it wrong.

I’ve been predicting rising unemployment for the last three years. I think it’s going above 5%, and possibly towards 6%. The real question is why.

The official story: interest rates

The mainstream view is that this is cyclical. The RBA has raised rates five times, and higher rates are designed to slow the economy. Now they’re biting. Once inflation is under control, rates come down and the jobs come back.

There’s some truth in that. My view is that it’s a mixture of cyclical and structural, and the structural part is the bigger worry.

Unemployment is a lagging indicator

Unemployment always runs on a lag. Businesses hold on to staff as long as they can. They cut hours, freeze hiring, and absorb the pain themselves. Then, when they can’t hold on any longer, the jobs tumble, and they tumble hard.

The jobs also take a long time to come back. A business that has cut staff, shrunk down, or closed doesn’t spring back to life the moment rates drop. That’s why I think we’re only at the start of this, not the end.

Why I believe it’s structural

I’ve been in kitchens for 36 years. I deliberately scaled my own business back because, between tax and wage costs, growing just wasn’t worth it. Sydney Private Chef could be five or six times the size it is today. I don’t offer overtime because it’s too expensive.

I’m not the only one. Right across hospitality and small business, owners are making the same call: stay small, stay safe, don’t hire. That isn’t a decision interest rates caused, and it isn’t a decision rate cuts will reverse. When it doesn’t pay to grow at any interest rate, you’ve got a structural problem.

The money is in the wrong places

People say there isn’t enough money in the economy. There’s plenty of money. The problem is where it’s sitting.

The 99% have been hammered by mortgage repayments, rents and prices, and their wages have barely kept up. Their money flows out to banks, landlords and the government in tax, not into cafes, restaurants and local businesses.

At the very top, people still have money, but they’re nervous. In my business I’m now seeing cracks in every market, including the top 1%. They aren’t broke; they’re holding back. So the people who would spend can’t, and the people who could spend won’t.

Are we in stagflation?

I think we’re in it, or very close to it. Costs are still rising, demand is fracturing, and unemployment is climbing. Officially the economy is still growing at around 2% a year, but per person it feels flat, and on the ground it feels like going backwards.

For a small business, stagflation is the worst squeeze there is. Costs keep going up, customers won’t wear higher prices, and margins get crushed from both sides.

What needs to change

Rate cuts alone won’t fix this. The government needs to make productivity an urgent priority. Getting more out of every worker and every dollar is how you bring inflation down without crushing jobs, and how you bring the economy back. But this problem has been years in the making. We should have been pulling the productivity levers years ago, not waiting until the gate is open and the horse has bolted. If we want small businesses to hire again, it has to make sense to grow. That means looking seriously at the tax, wage and compliance costs that make employing one more person a losing proposition.

Until the underlying economics change, expect unemployment to keep rising and to take a long time to come back down.

Sources

Add your voice

What’s hurting your business?

Tell me, and I’ll take it into my next interview.

More insights

All insights